Best Futures Trading Journal: 6 Journals Compared on Futures Criteria
We will not hand you a ranked top 10. A journal that suits a stock swing trader can be the wrong pick for someone scalping MNQ on three prop accounts. Below are the criteria that matter on futures, what each journal's own pricing page says, and which one fits which trader. We make MyTradeEdge, so judge our row with that in mind.
Five questions to answer before you pick a journal
- Can it get your trades in without retyping? Futures traders mostly run on Rithmic, Tradovate or NinjaTrader. Check that the journal syncs or imports from your exact platform, not just "500+ brokers".
- Does it get futures P&L right? One NQ point is $20, one MNQ point is $2. A journal built for stocks that ignores the contract multiplier will show nonsense. Import one day of trades and compare the P&L with your broker statement before you commit.
- Do you trade prop firm accounts? If yes, you need several accounts in one place and ideally a view of your drawdown and daily loss limit next to the trades.
- Do you really need trade replay? Replay is the main reason the more expensive plans cost more. Scalpers who review execution tick by tick use it. If you review setups, sizing and rule breaks, notes and statistics do the job.
- What will it cost after the trial? Compare monthly prices, not the yearly promo, unless you are sure you will still journal in 12 months.
The six journals side by side
Every competitor detail comes from that company's own pricing page, read on Oct 23, 2026: Tradezella pricing, TraderSync pricing, Tradervue pricing, TradesViz pricing, Edgewonk pricing. Where a page does not mention something, we write "not listed" instead of guessing. Prices change, so check before you buy.
| Journal | Free plan | Paid price (monthly billing) | Futures on the plan you would buy | Trade replay | Accounts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MyTradeEdge | Yes, no card, no time limit | Pro $14.99 / month (pricing) | Yes, on Free and Pro | No | Multiple, including prop firm accounts |
| Tradezella | Not listed | Essential $35, Pro $59, Ultra $99 (yearly: $26, $44, $74 / month) | Yes (journal and manual backtesting) | Pro and Ultra, 1-second chart | 1 / 50 / unlimited |
| TraderSync | Not listed; 7-day trial | Pro $29.95, Premium $49.95, Elite $79.95 (annual plans discounted) | Yes (Market Replay covers futures) | Yes, all three plans | 5 / unlimited / unlimited |
| Tradervue | Mentioned on the pricing page | Silver $29.95, Gold $49.95 | "Futures support" listed in the plan table | Not listed | Unlimited on Silver and Gold |
| TradesViz | Basic: stocks only, 3,000 executions / month | Pro $14.99, Platinum $22.49 per month billed yearly | Pro and Platinum only | Trading simulator (not tested by us) | 1 / 10 / 20 |
| Edgewonk | Not listed | $35 / month or $197 / year, one plan with every feature | Yes | Not listed | Unlimited, including prop firm accounts |
TraderSync showed a promotional discount on yearly plans on Oct 23, 2026; the table lists the regular monthly prices. TradesViz shows its paid prices billed yearly.
Which journal fits which trader
You scalp and want to replay every execution
Look at TraderSync or Tradezella. Both list trade replay: TraderSync on all paid plans, with updates down to 250 milliseconds; Tradezella on Pro and Ultra, on a 1-second chart. Replay starts at $29.95 a month on TraderSync Pro and $59 on Tradezella Pro.
You want the most statistics for the money
TradesViz lists 600+ charts and statistics and is among the cheapest paid options here ($14.99 a month, billed yearly). Note that its free Basic plan is stocks only, so a futures trader starts on Pro.
You work on discipline and psychology
Edgewonk sells one plan with every feature, including its Tiltmeter for rule breaks and MAE/MFE analysis, and lets you track unlimited prop firm accounts. It has no free plan, but $197 a year is predictable.
You already know Tradervue
Tradervue is one of the oldest journals, with broker sync, MFE/MAE statistics and mentoring on Silver and Gold. Its plan table lists futures support. Check that your futures platform is on its supported broker list before you pay.
You trade futures on prop accounts and want to start free
MyTradeEdge is built for this case. The free plan needs no card. There is no broker sync: you import a CSV of closed trades or the NinjaTrader 8 trade export. Prop firm accounts sit next to each other with the daily loss limit, maximum drawdown and profit target you set (drawdown counted from the starting balance), and an AI review grades each trade. What we do not have: trade replay, direct broker sync, and the long broker list of the older journals. Pro is $14.99 a month.
How to test a journal in one evening
- Export the last two weeks of trades from your platform.
- Import them into the free plan or trial of your top two choices.
- Check three numbers against your broker statement: net P&L, number of trades and commissions.
- Open your worst day and see whether the journal tells you something you did not already know.
The journal that passes step 3 and teaches you something in step 4 is the right one, whatever any list says. For a deeper look at two of the names above, read our TraderSync vs Tradervue vs MyTradeEdge comparison or the MyTradeEdge vs Tradezella page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best trading journal for futures?
There is no single best one. Choose based on four things: whether it imports from your platform (Rithmic, Tradovate, NinjaTrader), whether it tracks prop firm accounts, whether you need trade replay, and what you are willing to pay. Tradezella and TraderSync lead on replay, Edgewonk on psychology tools, TradesViz on analytics per dollar, and MyTradeEdge on a free start for futures and prop firm traders.
Is there a free trading journal for futures?
Yes. MyTradeEdge has a free plan with no credit card and no time limit. TradesViz has a free Basic plan, but its pricing page lists stocks only on Basic; futures need Pro. Tradervue mentions a free plan on its pricing page. Tradezella, TraderSync and Edgewonk do not list a free plan.
Do I need trade replay in a journal?
Only if you review execution tick by tick, for example scalpers who want to see why a stop was hit. If you mainly review setups, sizing and rule breaks, notes, screenshots and statistics cover most of it, and you can skip the more expensive replay plans.
Can a trading journal track prop firm rules?
Some can. MyTradeEdge shows the daily loss limit, maximum drawdown and profit target you set for each prop account (drawdown counted from the starting balance), and Tradezella lists a PropFirm Sync dashboard on its pricing page. Always check the limits against your firm's current rule page, because firms change them.
Run the one-evening test on MyTradeEdge
Import two weeks of futures trades and compare the numbers with your statement. Free plan, no credit card.
Start the free journalTradezella, TraderSync, Tradervue, TradesViz and Edgewonk are trademarks of their owners. MyTradeEdge is not affiliated with any of them. If a detail here is out of date, tell us and we will correct it.